roof | From The Beach

Do you need a Permit?

Flooring Visualizer

Relay or Replace?

Cement Tile Roof

Option 1 — Lift, Re-Paper, and Reuse the Existing Tile

Option 2 — Full Tile Roof Replacement

Homes built in 1980 to 2020 have a lot going for them — solid construction, great layouts, and often, classic cement tile roofs that define the neighborhood’s look. But if your roof is 20 years old or more and has a lot of cracked tiles, you’re likely facing a common (and important) decision:

Do you replace the entire tile roof, or do you remove the tile, install new underlayment, and put the same tile back?

For homeowners preparing to sell — or buyers evaluating a property — understanding this choice can make a big difference in cost, negotiations, and long-term value.

On most cement tile roofs, the tile isn’t what actually “wears out” first

— the underlayment does. That means:

The roof underlayment is very likely at the end of its life.
Cracked tiles are common on roofs this age.
Leaks often come from worn paper and flashing — not just broken tiles.

So even if the roof “looks fine from the street,” it may need attention underneath.

Option 1 — Lift, Re-Paper, and Reuse the Existing Tile

This is what many realtors and inspectors refer to as a “lift and relay.”

The process:

The contractor removes your existing cement tiles
Installs new, modern underlayment (often upgraded to synthetic)
Repairs or replaces flashing around vents, chimneys, and valleys
Reinstalls your original tiles

Why this can be a great option for sellers:

✔ Lower cost than full replacement — attractive for pre-listing repairs
✔ Keeps the home’s original curb appeal
✔ Environmentally friendly (less waste going to a landfill)
✔ Often satisfies lenders and buyers if done properly

What to consider:

Some cracked tiles may need to be replaced (expect 20% breakage)
If your tile is very brittle or discontinued, replacements could be harder to find
Your roof will still “look” the same when you’re done

For many sellers, this is the best balance between cost and marketability.

Option 2 — Full Tile Roof Replacement

This means everything comes off and you install a brand-new tile roof system.

Why some homeowners choose this:

✔ Completely new roof from top to bottom
✔ You can update the color or style of the tile
✔ No concerns about reused or brittle tile
✔ Strong appeal to buyers who want a “new roof”

The downside (especially for sellers):

✖ Much higher cost
✖ More construction time
✖ More waste
✖ Often more than buyers expect — or are willing to pay extra for

This option tends to make the most sense if:

The existing tile is badly damaged in many areas
You’re doing a major remodel
You want to modernize the home’s exterior look

What Buyers Will Care About Most

From a buyer’s perspective, the biggest questions are:

Is the roof watertight?
How long will it last?
Will I have to replace it soon after closing?